UK STAINED GLASS NEWS July 2006
and THE UK STAINED GLASS REGISTER

FOILERS - DOES PRICE MATTER?

WHICH FOILER?
by Ed Potterton

Many years ago, when I first bought a machine to apply copper foil, I was, like most newcomers to the game, totally driven by price. Nevertheless, I wanted the machine to do two things:

• speed up my work

• improve the quality of my foiling

In the UK there are two kinds of foilers that do this:

• Plastic bearings:
  Glastar and Inland etc.,
  
  
• Metal Bearings: Diegel Foiler

The plastic bearing foilers retail at around £30.00 and the Diegel at almost double that, at £50 odd.

Well, as far as I was concerned there was no contest, I bought a Glastar, although I think the Inland foiler is nicer looking.

Many years later, when I owned Broadland Stained Glass, I was sent a Diegel machine to try out.  I screwed it to the bench and gave it a go, and was hooked almost immediately.  Here are the differences:

• Tension:   The cheaper foilers set the tension by tightening or loosening a screw.  This is difficult to set, and later, as the wheels turn, the tendency is to tighten or loosen the screw.  The tension requires constant tweaking.  The Diegel on the other hand, sets the tension by means of push on clamps. It   remains as set.
• Wheels:  The Diegel wheels are a very hard plastic with a groove the exact size of the copper tape.  This means that the tape is kept in exactly the same position at all times.  You centre the glass on the tape by eye.  With the Glastar, the wheels apply and crimp together, so there it is very difficult to keep the tape centred.  There are glass guides, but they do not guide the glass, only your eye.  I found them unusable. Further, if the wheels are not set right, the tape will not run cleanly (no setting of the wheels required with the Diegel).
• The wheels on the Diegel are much smaller than the other brands, allowing machine foiling on a much tighter radius, and on smaller pieces of glass.
• Finish.  Because the Diegel does not attempt to process the tape as it passes through, it keeps the tape exactly flat on the wheels.  This allows the artist to accurately locate the glass edge on the tape.  When it is then hand crimped, it is found to be very even and neat: unbeatable

Just these three reasons alone were good enough for me to change forever.   Although the Glastar and Inland claim to crimp, they only part crimp and it is necessary to finish off the job.  The advantage of the tape being flat and therefore being able to exactly centre the glass, makes the Diegel result that bit better.

My recommendation:

• Diegel wins on manufacture quality (particularly the bearings)
• Diegel wins on quality of finish and speed
• Glastar and Inland win on price

Click here for the Tool Reviews menu

Tell a Friend About This Site

site menu

REGISTER YOUR URL:

We list sites from world wide.  All stained glass URLs are invited for consideration.  For a URL to be considered for the registers of Studios they must conform to all of the following criteria:

1. The site is primarily stained glass
2. The premises location has been made known to us
3. Any studio MUST be manufacturing its own stained glass items
4. Resellers of glass, hardware and patterns are not eligible for inclusion in the studio registers
5. We reserve the right to exclude any site

You should note that this is primarily a UK site. All bona fide UK studios, professional and amateur are usually listed. Sites from abroad or overseas, will only be listed if we think they would be interesting for our UK artists and visitors.

Like to send a letter to the editor?  Send it by e-mail.

Any errors on this site? Let the webmaster know!

BACK TO THE TOP OF THE PAGE